press room
 

Microclimate study helps conserve Roman murals

Sabatino Albero, Carlo Giavarini, Maria Laura Santarelli, CISTeC - Interdepartmental Centre of Science
and Technology of Historical and Architectural Conservation, University of Rome "La Sapienza", Italy


 
 

FISTeC (Interdepartmental Centre of Science and Technology for Historical and Architectural Conservation) has investigated thermofluid dynamics phenomena inside Domus Aurea in Rome, to understand the causes of decay of the ancient and precious mural paintings (fig. 1). Domus Aurea was Emperor Nero's residence (first century A.D) and is now completely below ground level. Based on previous studies on several historical hypogeum monuments (e.g. Hebrew Catacombs at Torlonia Villa in Rome, Catacombs in Tarquinia), CISTeC defined the optimal conditions for the conservation of paintings: air temperature: 17°C (± 2°C), relative humidity: 92% (± 5%), air velocity < 0.4 m/s.

With STAR-CD we studied the microclimatic changes (e.g. wind velocity, air temperature and its relative humidity) inside the rooms of Domus Aurea and how they differed from the above optimal values.

These simulations have been supported by experimental monitoring of the environmental parameters: air temperature, contact temperature of the walls, relative humidity of the air, wind velocity.

Simulations were especially concerned with the so called "Room with the Golden Vault" (fig.1), where openings in the masonry produced turbulent air flow.

Geometrical model of the room
The geometrical model of "Room with the Golden Vault" is 1:1 scale, the volume of air storage capacity is equivalent to 813.10 m3.

Environmental data and boundaries
We chose the microclimatic data for the months of January and August 2000, because they are the coldest and hottest periods of the year in Rome. In figure 2a the original case is shown with environmental average conditions (measured parameters). Other simulations of the original case were carried out changing only the wind velocity: the maximum and the minimum values of wind were chosen from the experimental measurements.

Finally, simulations were repeated using a modified condition where the openings in the masonry were closed (fig. 2b). We will show how this proposed modification brings potential benefits.

Results - August 2000
The three values of the inlet for this month are: average=0.09 m/s, minimum=0.03 m/s, maximum=0.73 m/s. There are no significant differences between the summer and winter cases for what concerns fluidodynamic and thermo-hygrometric distributions. It goes without saying that the absolute environmental values change.

The minimum values of air wind velocity is 0.26 m/s and the maximum value is 0.96 m/s.

The optimal value for the indoor air velocity (0.4 m/s) was exceed only in the maximum velocity case. In the other cases, the critical zones are: vault, pillars and western wall (fig. 3a). In summer the temperature difference between walls and air is lower than in winter. In summer the difference is 0.5°C with air temperature in the range 18.5 - 19 °C (fig. 3a), while in winter the difference is 2.1°C with air temperature in the range 7.6 - 9.7°C.

An isothermal profile of the inflow air is shown in fig. 4. The hygrometrical trend follows the winter case, but the specific humidity value is double. The higher wet zones are the north wall and the vault (fig. 5a). In the modified case the microclimatic conditions are better and close to the optimal values (fig. 5b).

Conclusion
In the original cases, the simulations led to the following results: The inflow air damages the masonry season in both seasons, but for different reasons:

  • In winter the optimal value is never reached
  • In summer optimal temperatures are
    achieved but the humidity is too high

In the modified masonry cases, simulations show that:

  • Microclimatic parameters are distributed more homogeneously>
  • The room is more insulated from the external environment

It is therefore easier to reach optimal values for air temperature and relative humidity and so guarantee the conditions for the conservation of the mural paintings.

"CISTec of Rome", says Anthony Massobrio of CD-adapco(Turin Office), "is a leading example on how to merge art and technology. What archaeologists discover, CFD studies help to preserve."

Read more - www.architectureweek.com/2003/0924/tools_1-1.html


Fig. 2 : Geometrical model of the "Room with Golden Vault" with the (a) inlet for original case and (b) modified case with closed openings


Fig. 3: average velocity, original case
(August 2000): (a) velocity map, (b) inlet
section of thermal distribution



Fig. 4: Isothermal distribution of the inflow air at18.9C (maximum velocity, original case
– August 2000)



Fig. 5:Hygrometrical distribution
(average velocity, August 2000): (a) original case and (b) modified case with closed openings

 
     
 
 
OpenCube Drop Down Menu (www.opencube.com)